Battle of the Eyeshadow Transformers

23 08 2009

By Taryn

Who will win? High end or low end?

An eyeshadow transformer is a liquid that turns any shadow color into a liquid liner. What you do is run the brush over your shadow and then apply to your lid just like applying liquid liner. (Word of caution on that: you may want to only use the transformer in a corner of your shadow pan and not all over, otherwise the surface may develop a strange texture. I personally prefer using loose shadows for this.) Or, if you’re using pigments like the MAC Golden Olive I used below, just tap a bit of pigment into the jar lid, dip your brush into it, mix it up a bit, and you have liquid liner. If the consistency seems a bit too thin, just add more pigment or shadow.

I believe Too Faced came out with one of the very first, but the ones I’ll be reviewing today are from Urban Decay and Jesse’s Girl. UD retails for $18, Jesse’s Girl is $5.99. The pictures will tell most of the story here.

First up, here are the two products:

Both have dual ends, one with a fine brush and the other a wider one:

As for brilliance of color, here they are side-by-side (UD left, JG right):

The final contest was staying power. Both dried to a durable, long-lasting finish and the color was true with each product – it wasn’t watered down or thin-looking.

Who wins? Jesse’s Girl, by a mile, just for the sheer value. Urban Decay’s product has a nicer fine-tip brush, but is it worth $12 more? No way. Both are terrific, brilliant products, but I will definitely buy the more inexpensive of the two so I can save my pennies and splurge on something more fabulous later (like, oh, I don’t know…maybe another shade of UD lipstick from their fall lineup?). I only wish I had found the Jesse’s Girl transformer first!

You can find Jesse’s Girl on their website and at Rite Aid stores; Urban Decay is at Sephora and on their website.

Both get a 10/10 rating for what they can do.  It’s just a matter of considering if you want to pay $12 more for a slightly nicer brush.  These are still two very high-quality products, no matter which you choose.

Advertisements

Actions

Information

2 responses

23 08 2009
Megan

Thank you!! I will be heading out to Rite Aid tomorrow~

25 08 2009
atlantaluxelashes

That looks really cool! Does the brush get stained with the shadow? Maybe it is something that could be cleaned and dried before putting back into the tube.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




%d bloggers like this: